Tilburg student demands 20,000 euros after false accusation of plagiarism
An international student at Tilburg University lost almost a year of study time after being falsely accused of plagiarism. He is now seeking 20,000 euros in compensation.

Tilburg University.
Plagiarism means using someone else’s work without being honest about it. It is a cardinal sin in academia. Researchers can be dismissed for it, and students can also face severe penalties.
An international student in Tilburg has been accused of it. But was the accusation justified? In a number of footnotes in his master’s thesis, he gave a brief summary of the sources he cites. He did so in his own words, but put them in quotation marks, as if they were a direct quote.
‘In principle, plagiarism’
His lecturer considered this serious and alerts the examination board. The board then labeled it ‘plagiarism’ and decided that the student had to write an entirely new thesis.
The student appealed, but is unsuccessful. Tilburg University’s Examination Appeals Board (CBE) ruled that an ‘inaccuracy in referencing is in principle plagiarism’.
But isn’t it strange to call this plagiarism? The student took the case to the Council of State. The judges asked the university: if this is plagiarism, exactly what did the student take from someone else?
Lower mark
The university maintained that it was plagiarism ‘because it mislead the reader’. The Council of State disagreed, as Wednesday’s ruling shows. In this case, the opposite of plagiarism had occurred: the student had attributed his own words to someone else.
It was clear that the student had used the quotation marks incorrectly. But the university can penalise him for that by giving him a lower mark. In fact, the judge noted, correct citation is one of the criteria on which students are assessed.
The student has therefore won his case, but by now he has already started writing a new thesis and has lost almost a year. He had to pay institutional tuition fees of around 20,000 euros and would like that money back. The judge will rule on the amount of compensation in a few weeks.
Een lijst met artikelen
-
Penalties for research misconduct are unfair, according to new dissertation
Gepubliceerd op:-
Science
-
Would you rather see EM than AI generated news in your search results? Add EM as a source in Google. Or just ignore the search engines and chatbots and use our mobile app instead.
De redactie
Comments
Read more in Education
-
Teaching students about money? Social affairs minister sees potential in it
Gepubliceerd op:-
Education
-
-
Few Caribbean students come to the European Netherlands on Kingdom scholarships
Gepubliceerd op:-
Education
-
Politics
-
-
Women perform better in education, but are less likely to receive a pre-university recommendation
Gepubliceerd op:-
Diversity
-
Education
-
Leave a comment