Maastricht University gives in to political intimidation
We must prevent hatred and violence from becoming commonplace in the future, says Ronald van Raak, professor of Philosophy.

Image by: Geisje van der Linden
The Israeli government has committed genocidal violence in Gaza. That is what I think, and I will continue to say so, even if it means facing accusations that this criticism is ‘antisemitic’. From supporters of Israeli prime minister Netanyahu. At the same time, I must defend people’s right to make this accusation against me. That is what makes us a democracy.
It is very important that a dissenting voice continues to be heard from within the Jewish community, not least because the accusations of genocide are so serious and because this is such a horrific war. People must be able to demonstrate freely against the Israeli government, but Jewish organisations must also be able to hold meetings and put forward their arguments.
Maastricht University banned a lecture at the Jewish students’ association this month, in response to the war. The reason was online threats from two pro-Palestinian groups at the same university. There were apparently no concrete indications of violence, but the Executive Board wanted to prevent groups from confronting one another.
Maastricht University likes to present itself as an international university. People who graduate here, like those from other universities, may go on to hold important positions in government, both nationally and internationally. In those roles, it is very important to learn how to engage with people whose views differ from your own.
The students’ association in Maastricht said that other events had also been banned in the past, following threats and intimidation. By people who claim freedom of speech for themselves, while at the same time trying to silence others. We must not allow that in a democracy, and certainly not at universities, which must always promote and defend academic freedom.
'Surely in a war you always have to pick a side? Well, no, not according to Erasmus'
Universities are not there to fight the wars of bad leaders, but to educate better leaders for the future. We must teach students that threats of violence and intimidation are not the answer, and that continuing to listen and think for themselves are essential. That starts here, at Erasmus University, and it must happen there too, at Maastricht University.
‘But surely in a war you always have to pick a side?’, you may be thinking. Well, no – not according to Desiderius Erasmus, the namesake of our university. In his day, he refused to choose between the Catholic pope and the Protestant Luther, and showed people the importance of thinking for themselves and continuing to seek peace, rather than joining in the violence.
‘The administrators in Maastricht didn’t want to get involved in the political mess’, might be the response. Well, that is unfortunate for them, because this is their job. Setting standards now and teaching these students that we will not accept threats and intimidation will no doubt cause a fuss. But we must also prevent hatred and violence from becoming increasingly commonplace in the future.
Een lijst met artikelen
-
Powerhouses are like shoulder pads
Gepubliceerd op:-
Column
-
De redactie
-
Ronald van RaakColumnist
Comments
Read more in Column
-
Quite a challenge: dealing with criticism from non-scientists
Gepubliceerd op:-
Column
-
-
Ctrl+F on paper
Gepubliceerd op:-
Column
-
-
Private joke
Gepubliceerd op:-
Column
-
Leave a comment